The Counters Blog

The Best Stand For 2018 – Reviews By Wirecutter Dough Mixer



Great mixers also have power hubs for extra accessories that can roll out pasta dough, grind meat, and even churn ice cream. If you bake or cook regularly and have been struggling with a low-grade or older stand mixer, or want to level up from a hand mixer, you might consider upgrading. But a stand mixer’s extra heft and power, and bigger bowl capacity, means you can make larger, more involved recipes with less effort. Tilt-head mixers tend to be more compact than bowl-lift mixers, and they make it easy to swap out beaters or to remove the bowl while the beaters are still attached. It’s a bit easier to add ingredients to a bowl-lift mixer than a tilt-head mixer when the bowl is lowered, but it’s also impossible to remove the bowl without also removing the beater attachment, which is a mildly annoying extra step.This action ensures more points of contact and thus more consistent mixing.

More money will likely get you more features and attachments, and for a tool that takes up a decent amount of counter space, we think it’s wise to get a multitasker. For the 2018 update, we repeated all of these tests, but made pizza dough instead of bread. The stated yield of this recipe is 8 cups, but getting more than that indicates better whipping abilities. Because the addition of flour in the last step of this recipe deflates the batter about 25 percent, it needs to be nice and airy to begin with to get tall, tender layers. And every step of the way we also took note of how easy each mixer was to use, clean, and store.


Christina Tosi’S Bread Dough In A Hobart Mixer | Duration 3 Minutes 46 Seconds

This model is also easy to wipe clean and comes with a pouring shield to keep mixing relatively mess-free. The beater and whisk have a nylon coating, which have held up during five years of long-term testing. It sounds minor, but when you have a bowl of dry ingredients in your hand, it’s annoying to have to set it aside to put the mixer in place. These hook onto the machine easily, and all are dishwasher safe except for the whisk. But in over five years of use, we’ve never noticed any chips. But we think that if you read the manual about maintenance and know the limitations of your mixer, you shouldn’t have issues with its longevity. But given that you can set a timer on your phone, this isn’t a huge concern. If you respect its boundaries, it will give you many years of service. If you’re willing to pay more for the extra mixing power, we think it’s best to go for the bigger bowl, since larger projects are where that powerful motor will really come into play. A stand mixer is a great way to take your baking game to the next level, but if you’re an occasional baker looking for something more compact and affordable, you may want to try a hand mixer instead. It’s easier to use than many other tilt-head mixers, and is one of the quietest we tested.

The Best Stand for 2018   Reviews by Wirecutter Dough Mixer

It can make quick work of whipping egg whites into meringue and heavy cream into an airy dessert topping. Hand mixers are lighter and more portable than stand mixers, and they’re great for occasional bakers or those with limited storage. With larger attachments and greater speeds, a stand mixer will handle tasks like creaming butter, aerating batters, or kneading dough more efficiently than a hand mixer. They tend to be larger than tilt-head mixers (since you need clearance to raise and lower the bowl), and they’re also typically sturdier and more stable so they can better handle thick doughs. Stationary mixers have two stationary beaters that spin while the bowl rotates in place and, as a result, doesn’t mix as thoroughly. When mixing heartier doughs, a stand mixer shouldn’t strain, smoke, or “walk” even when on its highest speed. It should be easy to lift or lock the head, add or remove beater attachments, attach splash guards, and secure the bowl to the base. These attachments are usually metal, sometimes with a nylon coating, and most are dishwasher safe. Some reviewers complain about the heavy weight of stand mixers, which is understandable if you have to pull one out of a cabinet or down from a shelf every time you need to use it. If you want something more portable, we recommend a hand mixer. With a larger bowl, the beaters will make less contact with small amounts of liquids or foods.

We also considered cost when looking for mixers to test.

We chose to make seven-minute frosting (which is the same as meringue) to test each mixer’s whipping prowess.

The Best Stand for 2018   Reviews by Wirecutter Dough Mixer

Besides noting whether the mixers strained during such a long, high speed task, we also measured the volume of the frosting to see how well each machine aerated the mixture.

We also made a genoise (a type of sponge cake), which requires whipping whole eggs with sugar to give the cake its light, fluffy texture. So to judge how well each mixer aerated the batter, we measured the height of the baked cakes (down to 1/16 of an inch) and looked for an even, delicate crumb. Then, we kneaded pizza dough, aiming for a springy, uniform ball that was resilient to the touch. Finally, to see if the mixers could handle small batch recipes, we used them to whip only one egg white, and then just ½ cup of cream. The motor runs much quieter than those of some of the other models we tested, too. Other mixers pushed ingredients high onto the sides of their mixing bowls, and we needed to stop multiple times to use a spatula to incorporate ingredients back down into the bowl. It yielded 9 cups of seven-minute frosting, proving that it can whip more air into a meringue than most of the other stand mixers we tested, which hovered in the still respectable range of 8¼ cups to 8½ cups. There’s a speed control lever on the left, a switch to lock the head down on the right, and a power hub for extra accessories in the front. This initially concerned us, but we’ve never actually had the head come crashing down on us.

You need both hands to work the mechanism: one to press the release button, the other to simultaneously raise or lower the head.



Equipment Review Best Stand Mixers & Our Testing Winner | Duration 6 Minutes 37 Seconds

If you notice chipping on the bottom edge of your beater, it’s likely that it’s sitting too low in the bowl.

You can easily clean the few crevices—the hinge, the spring where the attachments connect, and the bottom where the bowl snaps in—with a damp sponge or cloth (as long as you get at splashes while they’re still fresh). This is a tough machine favored by professional bakers and restaurant chefs. But like any small appliance with a motor, it’s important not to push it too far.

Frosted Pearl White Pro Line® Series 7 Quart Bowl Lift Stand Mixer by kitchenaid.com

Horsepower for our mixer motors was measured using a dynamometer, a machine laboratories routinely use to measure the mechanical power of motors. Simply put, our new, highly efficient, special purpose motor delivers the power you need when you need it. With over 14 different attachments, you can make everything from fresh pasta to burgers, veggie noodles, ice cream and more.



Commercial Reversible Dough Sheeter Mixers Grinder Bakery Mixer Restaurant Equipment | Duration 3 Minutes 12 Seconds

The rest are waiting for theirs or have asked for and received one from their spouse!

Unfortunately both of my units (original and warranty replacement) have been a big let down. The second one had a scary type of grinding noise and deposited metal shavings and oil/grease into my dough. I compared it to my two other mixers when making the dough again and they couldn’t even come close in performance. Called customer service, and received another defective, rusted bowl. I asked if they could at least inspect the bowl before sending and was told it wasn’t possible. My rating would be 5 stars, but my negative experience receiving a food safe bowl cancels out the good. When combined with and guided by our new advanced motor control board, this is our longest lasting and most efficient motor yet. I gave away my older one to a niece that is wanting to learn to bake. I have repeatedly tried the adjustments recommended in the manual that came with it to no avail. Turned it on to mix a cake and it started grinding and the ladle will now not turn.I made a double batch of croissant dough with no problem, not even the slightest tug on that motor. My one gripe is with a bowl lift mixer it’s difficult to into bowl to scrape or add ingredients (even with pour shield). I love my mixer but have had an enormous problems getting a non-defective bowl. It was packaged improperly with no padding and in a flimsy box. I have given up trying to receive a well made bowl, it just isn’t possible using kitchenaid’s quality control procedures. There is a chunk missing off the arm of the bowl lift, a chunk missing off the beater, and burrs inside the bowl from the welds of the handle.

Amazon: Vollrath 40756 10 Qt. Countertop Mixer With Guard: Electric Stand Mixers: by amazon.com

These compact tabletop mixers are small enough to fit into any kitchen yet robust enough for continuous use. Digital control panel to make easy speed shifts while unit is running. This is close to upper limit of what will fit in the 10 quart bowl. This is a sticky dough with an absorption ratio which allowed this much load. Even though the motor is rated at 1/3 horsepower the combination of the torque and direct drive all metal transmission make it a joy to use. Trying to work with their customer service was incredibly frustrating. Brand name sounds enticing until i tried using this item!

I was expecting it like in 3 minutes to achieve the maximum peak of my meringue but very disappointed!

I only used 6 cups of flours but still all the flour is everywhere down to the floor!

But the thorough performance is sorely lacking for my mini loaves. Five speed direct drive transmission, 100-percent gear driven. My first test was a large rye bread recipe which used 13 cups of flour.This mixer easily handled the mixing and kneading at speed 1. Really, sad as it’s a good mixer but needs to last loner than 26 months. It couldn’t even mix the same amount as 7 quarts could do?

The butter and sugar does not blend properly on the bottom or sides. My arms don’t hurt from stirring large bowls, it was all done by the mixer. Point of failure in this machine is a half a millimeter piece of cheap plastic. Problem is, the only way to lock the plastic guard in place is to twist it into a groove.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *